Showing posts with label Pledge from America. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Pledge from America. Show all posts

Thursday, September 23, 2010

Contract for America

The Republican "Pledge to America" is of course a muddle of contradictions: You can't reduce the deficit by extending the Bush tax cuts (and it doesn't bother to explain otherwise) and you can't ensure access to health insurance for patients with pre-existing conditions without mandates (and it doesn't bother to explain otherwise.

But one little remarked on pledge stands out to me: The promise to provide a constitutional justification for every bill passed. I realize that -- especially for major legislation -- this is generally vetted in advance. Nonetheless, isn't there the potential to politicize the judiciary by inserting it into the legislative process? After all, the only federal judges can truly give a constitutional thumbs up or down to a bill. Or perhaps the intent is the opposite: To render the judiciary irrelevant by determining constitutionality in advance.

Of course, there's always the possibility that this is an insincere nod to teabagger ignorance of the meaning of the separation of powers, and it won't actually go anywhere...

I must say that I resent the title of the pledge: I'm an American and I certainly am not signed up for this nonsense. I suppose, though, that since I don't see it precisely their way, the 'baggers question that I am an American...

More fun from Stan and Ollie: